I finally got to listen to the soundtrack for Phantom 2:
Love Never Dies, and the verdict is ...
Not as bad as I expected.
I actually like some of the music. There are hints of
Sunset and another show ...
Aspects, perhaps? I forget right now. And of course, the title song was originally heard in
The Beautiful Game (though with different lyrics).
However, the whole thing sounds much more entertaining than I had thought possible. I also forgive my initial reaction to the Coney Island setting. I think it works.
Obviously, this is no critique of the show (which I haven't seen, and whose
Broadway arrival has recently been postponed.)
I still think the show is probably going to be disappointing, if not completely awful. Why?
Raoul's character is a full 180 degree turn from the original. While that may happen in a real-life span of ten years (the time elapsed since we last saw him), audiences don't like to see such vastly different characters.
The Phantom, too, has lost most of his mystery ... his anger ... his devilishness ... that makes for such an intriguing character. Originally we pitied the Phantom for his situation, and yet were scared of him at the same time. But in the new production, he seems (on the soundtrack) to be just ... meh.
Overall the production appears to be lacking the pathos and horror that made the original such an entertaining phenomenon. The Phantom story is more than just a love story, it's a Gothic horror story surrounded by romanticism. I love the original set design for just such a reason: beautiful drapery could quickly create claustrophobia while the ornate Opera House was really just a facade for the dungeon below.
But perhaps the most egregious error is the plot point the entire show hinges on:
Beneath a Moonless Sky is completely laughable in its total disregard for the original story. Listen to the song and then return to the cast recording of Phantom 1. No where can I find a plausible explanation for the events that transpired between Phantom 1 and 2.
And perhaps, ultimately for me, that will be the downfall of the show.
Rumor has it, the show will be undergoing major revisions before the Broadway transfer. Many have especially criticized the musical's lyrics.
Yes, okay. But I'd rather see some major retooling of the characters and their story.
We shall see what happens.
Until then ... I'll continue to enjoy the cast recording, for I actually rather enjoy the music.