I thought it was a hideous idea at first:
*A sequel to one of the most famous and successful musicals of all time?
*A continuation of the haunting, gothic, mysterious Phantom's life?
*Coney Island? Really?
And the reviews are all over the place.

However, one thing is for sure. There's lots of buzz.
Will it be as successful as the original? Doubtful. But if it flops I want to be there! And if it does succeed, I want to cheer it on!
Why? The idea of a successful sequel intrigues me. It's practically uncharted territory. Not that I want the musical sequel genre to gain traction. I'd rather see some new shows being developed.
But I give Sir Webber credit. He's willing to take one heck of a calculated risk!
What do you think? Want to see Phantom 2: Love Never Dies?
UPDATE: here are a few articles that kind summarize the Phantom sequel experience. The Daily Mail review and The Telegraph review.